The Best Mallet Putters of 2023

#1 – Cleveland Huntington Beach Soft – Best Choice

Selling Points:

• Milled face
• 304 stainless steel
• Speed Optimized Face Technology

Cleveland gets overlooked a lot when it comes to putters but this is one that you will not want to sleep on if you prioritize a nice-feeling, forgiving putter. The milling pattern on the face is like a bunch of small diamonds which creates more friction with the ball.

This gives you a crisp feel on contact and helps the ball start it’s true roll almost immediately. This is a great-feeling putter as well. It has a soft feel but you still get a lot of control and forgiveness. This would be a great putter for players with a straight or arced putting motion because it’s very consistent.

Even if you don’t hit the center of the face, you can count on the Cleveland Huntington Beach Soft putter to give you an accurate roll.

Pros:

• Feels great
• Great accuracy
• Rolls smooth

Cons:

• A bit heavy
• A bit smaller than traditional mallet putters

Overall Rating: 95/100

Check Out More Reviews Here:

#2 – TaylorMade Spider GT – Best Premium

Selling Points:

• Steel side wings
• Customizable
• Pure Roll face insert

This is one of the coolest putters we have ever tested. And even if you don’t like the way it looks, you can change it. The TaylorMade Spider GT can be highly customized. You can choose the head color, sightline, face insert, sole plate and weights.

The TaylorMade Spider GT is about as modern a mallet style putter as you can find in 2022. The wings on either side of the head each weigh 90 grams so you get plenty of helpful perimeter weighting. The alignment marker is a bit simple and easily missed but this is still a very forgiving putter overall.

This would be a great choice for anyone who wants a great-looking putter but still needs a good amount of forgiveness.

Pros:

• Looks great
• Urethane face insert feels soft
• Limited skipping

Cons:

• Expensive
• Doesn’t sound great

Overall Rating: 96/100

Check Out More Reviews Here:

#3 – WILSON Infinite Men’s Golf Putter – Best Value

Selling Points:

• Double milled face
• Grid alignment markers
• Counter-balanced shaft

We really liked this putter because it has really unique and useful features but it doesn’t cost a boat-load of money. The WILSON Infinite Men’s Golf Putter has a grid-style alignment marker which consists of both perpendicular and parallel lines.

This is a great feature for any player who relies on alignment markers a lot. It allows you to visualize your intended path very easily. The counter-balanced head and shaft give this putter a really smooth and easy feel too.

You just feel like you have more control over the putter when you have it in your hands and at point of address. You get all that plus a nice anti-glare finish for a very good price which is what makes the WILSON Infinite Men’s Golf Putter such a great value.

Pros:

• Nice matte black finish
• Good for high handicappers
• Affordable

Cons:

• The black finish chips off easily
• Not great for low handicappers

Overall Rating: 94/100

Check Out More Reviews Here:

#4 – Odyssey Stroke Lab Black Putter Bird Of Prey

Selling Points:

• Multi-material shaft
• Micro hinge star face insert
• Large footprint

This is one of the largest putters we tested for this list. All the notes we got from the testers about this putter had the word forgiveness in them. This is an incredibly forgiving putter thanks to the massive head.

Now you would think that would mean that this is an exceptionally heavy or unbalanced putter; but just the opposite is true. Because the shaft is made of a composite of steel and graphite, it only weighs 75 grams which is a huge weight savings.

The Odyssey Stroke Lab Black Putter Bird Of Prey also looks really cool and modern at point of address. This would be a great choice for any high handicapper or beginner player.

Pros:

• Extremely forgiving
• Looks great
• Highly visible alignment marker

Cons:

• Face-balanced configuration is your only option
• Gets dings easily

Overall Rating: 93/100

Check Out More Reviews Here:

#5 – PXG 0211 Lightning Putter

Selling Points:

• 303 stainless steel design
• Pyramid face pattern
• Runway reticle alignment system

The PXG 0211 Lightning Putter has a 380 gram head so it’s not the lightest putter on the market; but we really loved the way this thing made the ball roll. The forward spin is started almost immediately thanks to deeper than normal face grooves.

There is a bit of skip on longer putts but that’s to be expected for the most part. This putter still feels really nice at impact even if you miss the center of the face. The 303 stainless steel design gives it a nice, crisp sound at impact as well.

The alignment marker feels a bit busy but some of our testers likened to it an arrow pointing to the ball which was helpful in some cases. Of course, it being a PXG club, the PXG 0211 Lightning Putter looks really nice in the bag too.

Pros:

• Feels durable
• Crisp sound
• Fast, smooth roll

Cons:

• A bit heavy
• The alignment marker looks a bit busy

Overall Rating: 94/100

Check Out More Reviews Here:

#6 – TaylorMade Golf TP Patina Ardmore Putter 1

Selling Points:

• Single-bend shaft
• Pure Roll face insert
• Patina finish

This is another really nice-looking putter. The patina finish is basically a nickel and copper plating that gives this putter a really unique and premium look. This would be a great choice for players with a straight back and through stroke because it’s face-balanced.

The single bend shaft also offers an unobstructed view of the face from point of address. The TaylorMade Golf TP Patina Ardmore Putter 1 also gets the Pure Roll treatment which is Taylormade’s signature face insert.

In the TaylorMade Golf TP Patina Ardmore Putter 1, the insert is a bit thicker giving it a deep, rich sound at impact.

Pros:

• Looks great
• Adjustable weights
• Good for a wide variety of players

Cons:

• The feel is deadened a bit by the thicker face insert
• The head cover feels cheap

Overall Rating: 94/100

Check Out More Reviews Here:

#7 – Mizuno M CRAFT Putter

Selling Points:

• Forged construction
• CNC milled
• Adjustable weights

Mizuno doesn’t play around when it comes to manufacturing. You can feel the love, attention and effort that went into making the Mizuno M CRAFT Putter. It’s forged from 1025 mild carbon steel so it has a soft feel.

The face was painstakingly milled and is incredibly consistent overall. This would be a great choice for any player who loves a nice-feeling putter but is also looking for a high degree of forgiveness. It should be noted though that only the M Craft VI, V and III models are actually mallet putters.

Still, you get a lot of options whether you have moderate arc or a straight back and through putting motion.

Pros:

• Many toe hang options
• Feels amazing
• Very consistent

Cons:

• Pricey
• Expensive head cover

Overall Rating: 96/100

Check Out More Reviews Here:

#8 – TaylorMade Big Red OSCB Monte Carlo Putter

Selling Points:

• Counter-balanced design
• Milled face
• Oversized head

This is another putter with a very large footprint so it is inherently forgiving. While feel is certainly lacking, overall we think this would be a solid choice for any high handicappers or beginners. The head is nice and heavy so you get a bit more control on longer putts than normal.

The alignment marker also runs the length of the head so it’s very easy to get on your intended line. The counter-balanced weighting is also great for making your stroke smoother. The bottom line is that this club will increase the accuracy of your putts 9 times out of 10.

Pros:

• Extremely forgiving
• Nice red and black finish
• Nice-looking head cover

Cons:

• Durability issues
• A lot of the feel is muted

Overall Rating: 93/100

Check Out More Reviews Here:

#9 – Tour Edge Pure Feel Template Series Putter 2019

Selling Points:

• Micro groove technology
• Semi-mallet design
• 304 stainless steel

We were pretty surprised after testing this putter because you can get it for around $100. The Tour Edge Pure Feel Template Series Putter 2019 combines a 304 stainless steel body with a CNC milled face. The top line has also been sand-blasted so you don’t get glare on sunny days.

This is a putter that looks and feels like a premium putter but with a very reasonable price. The micro groove face pattern makes for a very fast and smooth roll while the oversized stock grip is very easy on the wrists.

You won’t have to tense up so much to gain good control over this putter. For this reason, we would highly recommend the Tour Edge Pure Feel Template Series Putter 2019 to senior players. This is a semi-mallet putter so it’s not the most forgiving; but there is still enough rear weighting to cover most of your mis-hits.

Pros:

• It’s a great value
• Looks great at point of address
• The stock grip is comfortable

Cons:

• It’s not the most forgiving putter
• Durability issues

Overall Rating: 94/100

Check Out More Reviews Here:

#10 – Odyssey Golf 2022 Eleven Putter

Selling Points:

• Multi-material Stroke Lab shaft
• TPU sole insert
• White Hot face insert

Odyssey putters are the stuff of legend so it only seems fitting that we feature another one on our list of the best mallet putters of 2022. The Odyssey Golf 2022 Eleven Putter in particular has modern features that will help a variety of players.

First of all, the footprint is pretty significant but the overall weight isn’t too much. That’s thanks to a multi-material shaft that is lighter than normal steel. The steel section of the shaft is actually shortened to save even more weight.

The Odyssey Golf 2022 Eleven Putter features the prized White Hot face insert which is incredibly reliable and consistent. It feels nice and really helps on longer putts when feel and accuracy are of the utmost importance. There is a lot to love here but it’s not all great news.

The alignment marker wasn’t very helpful which was a bit of a disappointment considering how expensive this putter is.

Pros:

• Lightweight design
• Performs great on longer putts
• Very high MOI

Cons:

• The alignment marker isn’t very good
• A bit on the expensive side

Overall Rating: 94/100

Check Out More Reviews Here:

#11 – LAZRUS Premium Black Golf Putter

Selling Points:

• 380 gram head
• Micro milled face
• Forged construction

LAZRUS may not be the first company you shop when you are looking for a new putter; but at around $70, you would be foolish to completely overlook the LAZRUS Premium Black Golf Putter. That’s because it has premium appointments for a putter in this price range.

First of all, it’s a forged putter so you get excellent feel, consistency and durability. Secondly, the LAZRUS Premium Black Golf Putter features a micro milled face which affords great spin control to anyone who uses it – and we do mean anyone.

This was one of the few putters on our list that all of our testers were able use successfully. They noted that it increased accuracy and made it very easy to get the ball rolling smoothly. It has a pretty basic design so the looks aren’t anything to write home about; but what it lacks in beauty it makes up for in accuracy.

Pros:

• It’s an incredible value
• Black finish
• Comfortable stock grip

Cons:

• The hosel doesn’t seem very durable
• Not the best-looking putter on our list

Overall Rating: 93/100

Check Out More Reviews Here:

#12 – Odyssey EXO Putter

Selling Points:

• Stroke Lab shaft
• Multi-material head design
• White Hot micro hinge face insert

Surprised to see our list end with yet another Odyssey putter? Well you shouldn’t be because Odyssey makes some of the best putters in the world. The Odyssey EXO Putter combines bold looks with incredibly high MOI. The Odyssey EXO Putter features an aluminum outer design and a 17-4 stainless steel core.

This allowed Odyssey to relocate almost all of the weight away from the face so you end up with an extremely high MOI rating. The Odyssey EXO Putter is a fast putter so just keep that in mind. The top spin gets started almost immediately and you won’t have to put much oomph behind your stroke even if you are facing a putt that’s more than 25 feet away from the hole.

With the Odyssey EXO Putter, you get a 2-ball alignment system which is a nice feature for mid and high handicap players. Overall though, we think this putter would be a great choice for anyone who is struggling with accuracy on the green because of the ridiculously high MOI.

Pros:

• It’s very forgiving
• Very cool design
• Great overall feel

Cons:

• Definitely not great for scratch players
• It doesn’t sound great

Overall Rating: 96/100

Check Out More Reviews Here:

Final Assessment

Mallet style putters are usually geared toward higher handicap players who are seeking more forgiveness but pretty much any kind of player can use them which is what makes them so versatile and desirable.

While any of the putters on our list of the best mallet putters of 2022 would be a great choice for mid to high handicappers, we really liked the TaylorMade Spider GT. It has everything a good mallet putter should have: excellent feel and forgiveness. Plus, it just looks cool.

Check out the TaylorMade Spider GT and all the other putters on our list to play your best round ever!